United States-English

The Digital Mindset Blog

Dissociative Identity Marketing

Published 10 September 2006, 04:46 PM

Marketers have recognized the need for a fundamental re-design of marketing practices linked to the technology-driven explosion of media vehicles, from the Internet, to cable TV, blogging or gaming. They have reacted by shifting their advertising budgets from traditional TV and print to online media. They are now experimenting with new technologies and viral marketing.

However, new technologies are enabling a more subtle shift that marketers have yet to recognize and adapt to – I call it “dissociative identity marketing”. In medical terms, “dissociative identity” refers to the existence in an individual of two or more distinct identities, each with its own pattern of perceiving and interacting with the environment. “Dissociative identity marketing” would refer to the relationship a brand establishes with the various personas of a consumer, from the blogging persona, to the social network persona or the gaming persona.

This phenomenon is not entirely new to marketers: they have had to grapple with the “dissociative identity” of their business customers, who are also consumers. The CIO of a Fortune 100 company could be interacting with HP on a $100 million IT outsourcing deal and on a $79 personal printer purchase for his daughter at the same time, but with different perceptions and interactions.

In these new cases, brands will have to act very carefully and respect online communities to avoid creating backlashs.

Blogging personas: understanding blogging personas can be complex for marketers as they tend to be fairly dissociated from their real life personas. At the same time, targeting blogging personas does not necessarily guarantee that you will reach their real life counterparts. Pete Blackshaw has IMHO one of the best written posts on the much blogged about “Snakes on a Plane” viral marketing campaign. He highlights that word of mouth spread through marketing bloggers who were enthusiastic about a studio inviting their consumers to “participate” but the core message and the core targeting did not necessarily reach the real life moviegoers.

Social networking personas: MySpace has introduced a blended form of advertising, allowing brands to create their own online personas to interact with social networking personas. Brands can have their own pages and their own friends’ lists. A great example is the viral marketing campaign organized by FOX on Myspace for the release of X-Men as reported by Search Engine Lowdown. He highlights some of the smart uses of social networking personas and the strong success of this campaign (at least as measured in terms of number of friends). BL Ochman reports in a recent post on other surprising examples such as Gil the Crab for the Honda Element, where the crab sounds off on the supposed decision to exclude him from upcoming Element TV ads.

Gaming personas: Nowhere is the development of brand personas more fascinating than in Second Life, the much hyped virtual reality world built by its 300 000 “residents”. New members can create avatars that interact with a new world, enjoy new experiences and connect with other virtual reality avatars. According to a great Business Week article, residents spend a quarter of the time they're logged in, a total of nearly 23,000 hours a day, creating things that become part of the world, available to everyone else. It would take a paid 4,100-person software team to do all that, says Linden Lab. Assuming those programmers make about $100,000 a year, that would be $410 million worth of free code work over a year.

Brands have been quick to react to the opportunity to establish themselves first in the virtual “Second Life” world and interact with the avatars. Digital Media Wire has an article on the “firsts” from second life. For example, Starwoods Hotels will be opening a new line of moderately priced loft hotels and is testing the concept by having the first hotel built in Second Life. Similarly American Apparels opened a virtual store in Second life where items cost only $1 and has starting hiring virtual sales clerks. Kevin Maney even reports in his blog that Former Virginia governor (and rumored 2008 presidential candidate) Mark Warner has an avatar in Second Life.

So what do you think? Is “dissociative identity marketing” the latest fad or the ultimate customer centric marketing?

UPDATE: very interesting second life avatar marketing panel hosted by the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School

Posted By Eric Kintz | 11 Comments | Trackbacks | Permalink
Filed under:


Comments

I think as companies become more familiar with each form of social media, they will start to understand what value their customers get from each medium, and how they can better serve them. It's just going to take time for companies to get up to speed, and the only way to do that is to spend time using these new forms of communication.
# Sunday, September 10, 2006 09:01 PM by MCollier71
Great post and good question. I tend to think of these as different "touch points" but they do require different strategies as people do exhibit different preferences--and personalities--through these technologies. Marketing has always been rooted in psychology (understanding needs/wants/desires) but these new mediums go deeper into understanding how to relate to the consumer across these multiple 'dimensions'. That said, this one requires more thought...so I'll have to think on it as what you've pointed out has so many implications in treating our customers right across so many touchpoints. Many opportunities to soar, or stumble.
# Sunday, September 10, 2006 09:20 PM by ckEpiphany
Great Post Erik - agreed, the reality is simply that marketers can not "call the shots" any more, they need to adapt and embrace the opportunites and challenges of the so called Web 2.0, if marketing is abll about understanding needs (and psychology of consumers of consumers) then real and great marketing will help company succeed in the future... both tougher, but what a way to lead the company destiny... So, not a fade, a reality that will only accelerate... Again, great post! and indeed tricky but fascinating question! keep going.. Laurent Flores
# Sunday, September 10, 2006 10:11 PM by crmmetrix
I find it hard to take HP's interest in 21st century marketing seriously when they can't even get a simple thing right like friendly URLs. Eric, why is that hp.com/blogs redirects to http://h71028.www7.hp.com/enterprise/cache/104417-0-0-0-121.html? I mean, what's with these license plate URLs, anyway? Disclaimer: I'm an HP employee. This comment is my own and does not necessarily represent the opinion of my employer.
# Friday, September 15, 2006 12:08 AM by rfrbweg02@sneakemail.com
Tim - I also saw your post on an HP internal blog and posted a comment. Thanks for your thoughts on the URL. The hp.com domain strategy is set up to support content management and hosting convergence strategies. Therefore, it distinguishes between domain names used for "marcom" purposes and those used for server hosting. The marcom domain names are easy to remember, such as hp.com/go/blogs to get to the main page and "hp.com/blogs/kintz" to get to my blog - Eric
# Friday, September 15, 2006 01:39 PM by Eric Kintz
Mack, CK, Laurent - Thanks for your great comments. I agree that we are at the beginning of a journey and it will take time to test and figure out what works. Shel Holz ("A Shel of my former self") and Peter Kim at the Forrester Marketing Blog had also great follow ups on this post - Eric
# Monday, September 18, 2006 02:11 PM by Eric Kintz
Thanks for visiting ThreeMinds.organic.com - it's a small world. Organic worked on the MySpace/Xmen campaign. It was a great way to connect MySpace users with the popular characters. We also added some code that gave Xmen friends a "super-power"- the ability to have 16 featured friends instead of 8. I think that's a common thread that binds all the DIM examples you cite- consumers are smart enough to know when they are being marketed to, no matter how hip the brand or how skillful the adaption to a platform. To win their attention, you have to offer them something for their time. American Apparel, for example, offers Second Life visitors coupons that can be redeemable in real-world stores. -Misha
# Tuesday, September 19, 2006 05:43 PM by mcornes
Forget the URL foolishness; try getting a hold of someone at HP. Call the switchboard and ask for marketing, and not have a name, and see how far you get. The recording telling me that my ‘call may be recorded’ is more friendly than any HP person I’ve ever spoke to. I’m not going to use this post to plug another product; but I will say that every printer I’ve bought, or recommended, over the past few years is NOT an HP product. I remember when I used to plug HP products and recommend them; but till HP learns some manners I’ll take my business elsewhere. One of my criteria for selecting a product is how well I’m treated when I decide to call out of the blue and have no specific contact info. If I’m calling for some ‘pre-sales technical support’ that means that I want to speak with an engineer, or a technician, because I have a specific question I need answered immediately (because I’m at a customer site and don’t want to waste time looking stupid in front of people who have asked me a question by having to try and get a distributor’s tech person back on the phone and get told, again, that he doesn’t know the answer.)
# Monday, September 25, 2006 06:40 PM by Kuni_Leml
Misha- thanks for sharing your experience with My Space, very interesting- Eric
# Thursday, September 28, 2006 02:26 AM by Eric Kintz
Kuni- If you can give me specifics, I am happy to look into it-Eric
# Thursday, September 28, 2006 02:28 AM by Eric Kintz

Join us today as we discuss The Vaccine Book b y Robert W. Sears. This is the second time that contributors of Silicon Valley Moms Blog , Chicago Moms Blog, DC Metro Moms Blog and NYC Moms Blog (along with the rest our friends throughout the blogsphere

# Wednesday, July 23, 2008 08:07 AM by Stay at home mom resource for making extra money online.

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  


Type the digits above:
Information disclosed in this community becomes public. Exercise caution when deciding to disclose your personal information. HP reserves the right, but is not obligated to, edit or remove your comment if it contains personally identifiable information or other content HP deems unacceptable.  Opinions expressed are your personal opinions or those of the original authors, and not of HP. Please see HP's web Terms of Use for more details.